Is there a Sophomore Jinx?

McNally Robinson, the large indie chain of Canadian bookstores, was kind enough this week to run an editorial indicating that my second book, The Poisoned Pawn, had escaped the sophomore jinx. (The story refers to G.B. Joyce, another Penguin author; I’m really pleased to hear of his success with The Code.)

Apparently, the sophomore jinx is when a second book doesn’t live up to expectations.

Wikipedia calls this the sophomore slump. Among other things, the term is apparently used to refer to the slump a lot of baseball players experience in their second year. It brings back awful memories of second year law school. I still have nightmares sometimes of exams I didn’t know I was supposed to write.

I confess I have worried about this issue a fair amount and more so recently, with the second book about to hit bookstores. 

When you write your first novel, you put your best stuff in it. You have the luxury of time. (They say in music you have a lifetime to make your first album but two weeks to make your second.) Every author I know agonizes over that first book; how it will be received, whether the reviewers will love it or hate it, what readers will think.  But the ones I know who write series seem to worry more about the second. If the first book does well, it sets the bar high. What if you can’t make the jump with the next one?

In your first book, you can revise away to your heart’s content. The great lines you’ve saved on scraps of paper find a home; you get to reveal the interesting facets of your characters for the first time. Are they as interesting the second time? Will what was quirky in the first book become predictable?

There are certainly exceptions to the sophomore hex.  Lovely Bones was a second book. So was Pride and Prejudice. I’m sure there are many others that became break-through novels.

For many mystery authors it’s the second book that carries the series. You have to get through it. It’s not like the 13th floor in a building; you can’t just rename it and pretend it’s something else.

The Poisoned Pawn will be the acid test of whether the Inspector Ramirez series has legs or not. We’re only three weeks from publication. I’m having those dreams again about failing my exams.

This entry was posted in Writing and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Is there a Sophomore Jinx?

  1. MishaBurnett says:

    Yeah, I’m working on my second novel now, and I am struggling with those issues. As a movie buff, I have been thinking about film franchises that take off, and one common characteristic is the strength of the second film. It seems to be that a good first work leads to a sequel, and a good sequel leads to a series. In the first work everything is new and interesting, and the novelty can carry the audience a long way, in the second you find out if the characters and the world can maintain the audience’s interest once the mystery fades.


    • Peggy Blair says:

      I think you’re absolutely right, Misha. The hard thing to is figuring out how much of the first book’s plot to give away in the second. I really struggled with that; still not sure I got it right. Good luck with yours!


  2. Best of luck to you, Peggy. A strong writer like you has so many ways to reach an audience. You’ve found your voice and created a following. Go, Peggy, go!


  3. Peggy Blair says:

    Thanks so much, Sandi! Hope things are going well for you and that brilliant book of yours! Saw the article where you were quoted about self-publishing it and I thought, way to go, girl!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s